GovXRay
Method
This page explains what GovXRay’s figures measure, how they are calculated and the limitations of comparing them. Select a topic to explore the method and an example.
Reading the figures
Each figure on screen names what it measures, the scope it covers, its unit and its period. This topic explains how to read figures before comparing them.
Units
An amount is published as a total or per capita. A per-capita amount is a division: the official amount for the scope divided by the population of that same scope, for the year shown. It is an accounting average, not a sum paid or received by each person.
A ratio to GDP uses the GDP of the same territory and year. A missing GDP stays named; it is not replaced by another territory’s GDP.
Periods
Each amount carries its source’s fiscal year. Not every fiscal year follows the calendar year: the Canadian federal government closes on March 31, the US federal government on September 30.
When the tiers on one page do not share a fiscal year, each row shows its own. A total that would combine fiscal years too far apart is not published.
Stocks and flows
Spending, revenue and the balance are flows: they measure what comes in and goes out during a fiscal year. Assets and liabilities are stocks: they measure what is held or owed at a closing date.
A stock divided by annual GDP compares a value at one date with a year of output; the ratio’s label says so.
Currency
Each amount is first read in its source currency. The currency selector in the top bar converts the display using the average of European Central Bank daily rates over the fiscal-year window, or failing that the International Monetary Fund annual series.
Conversion changes the unit, not the calendar or the accounting framework. Rates, percentages and ratios are outside currency conversion.
Worked example
Next to the result, the page shows the item (spending), the scope (the tier that publishes the account), the unit (CAD per capita) and the fiscal year. Converted to USD, the same result is divided by that fiscal year’s CAD per USD rate; the number of residents does not change.
The item name, scope and unit are part of the figure: they are written next to it, not only in a tooltip, because a touch screen has no hover. A gap is written in words: not published, population missing, comparison not allowed.
Understanding the stack
A resident is served by several governments: the municipality, sometimes a region or province, a state or national government, and funds such as social security. The government stack shows them together, each one still named.
Tiers
Five scopes appear on the site, named next to the figure:
- city
- the municipality and its municipal accounts;
- metro or urban area
- the OECD functional urban area, distinct from the municipality;
- province or state
- the intermediate tier;
- country
- the national government or a national aggregate;
- stack
- every tier serving the same resident, each one labelled.
A metropolitan or country figure is never presented as a city figure. The word Federal names a federation (Canada, the United States, Germany, Austria, Australia, Brazil, Mexico). In a unitary state, the top tier is called National; Switzerland says Confederation.
Tiers by country: local name, information sought and where it appears
The table follows the publication register (37 countries open today). A paused country is named, with its reason, on the Coverage page.
| Country | Tier, local name | Information sought | Public label | Where it appears |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Published countries (37): what readers can see today | ||||
published | FEDERAL | Monthly Treasury Statement: federal taxes, social contributions, spending by function, federal deficit. | Federal (United States). Division by the population of the United States. Not National. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| State | Census ASLGF, individual unit files: revenue and spending of the federated state. | State, in the state's name (New York, California, …). Division by that state's population. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Municipality | Census ASLGF: municipality revenue and spending. Municipal assets: not published (Census does not publish the balance sheet). County: not published, named. | Municipality, in the municipality's name. Division by municipal population. This is not the whole stack. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | FEDERAL | Federal public accounts (AFR): taxes, contributions, spending by function, deficit. Debt and assets of the federal government (GFS). | Federal. Division by Canada's population. Not National: Canada is a federation. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Province | Provincial public accounts: provincial taxes, health and education when the province pays, provincial balance sheet. | The name of the province (Quebec, Ontario, …). Division by that province's population, not Canada's. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Municipality | Municipal accounts (MAMH, FIR, MFS, LGDE depending on the province): local taxes, services, municipal balance sheet. | Municipality, in the city's name. Division by municipal population. This is not the whole stack. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Eurostat, central government: national taxes, spending by function, financing requirement. | National (central government, Staten). Division by Denmark's population. Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Region | Region accounts (REGR): health above all. The region has no tax power: it is financed by the state. | Region, in the region's name (Hovedstaden, …). Division by that region's population. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Kommune | Statbank REGK: local taxes, services, municipal balance sheet. | Kommune, in the municipality's name. Division by municipal population. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Eurostat, central government: national taxes, spending by function, financing requirement. | National (central government, Rijk). Division by the population of the Netherlands. Not Federal: this is not a federation. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Provincie | CBS Iv3, provincie accounts: provincial taxes, state grant, spending. Provincial stock: not published, named. | Provincie, in the provincie's name (Noord-Brabant, …). Division by that provincie's population. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Gemeente | CBS Iv3, gemeente annual accounts: local taxes, services, municipal balance sheet (assets and liabilities). | Gemeente, in the municipality's name. Division by municipal population. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Eurostat: state and social security (S13 excluding the local sector). National taxes, functions and balance. | National (state and social security). Divided by Estonia's population. Not Federal. There is no regional tier. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Local sector excluding the city | The rest of the local sector, once the published municipality is removed. This is not a region: it is a named residual. | Local sector excluding the city. Not Province, not Region. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Municipality | Municipality accounts (Tallinn, Tartu): revenue, spending, functions. | Municipality, in the city's name. Division by municipal population. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Eurostat: state and social security (S13 excluding the local sector). National taxes, functions and balance. | National (state and social security). Divided by Lithuania's population. Not Federal. There is no regional tier. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Local sector excluding the city | The rest of the local sector, once the published municipality is removed. This is not a region: it is a named residual. | Local sector excluding the city. Not Province, not Region. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Municipality | Municipality accounts (Vilnius, Kaunas, Klaipėda): revenue, spending, functions. | Municipality, in the city's name. Division by municipal population. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | State accounts (central government), separate from regions and municipalities. Not an aggregate that merges them. | National (state). Not Federal: France is not a federation. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Region | Region accounts, separate from the state and the municipality. | Region, in the region's name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Municipality | Municipality accounts. Department and intercommunality: separate when the source publishes them. | Municipality, in the city's name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | National (Staten). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Region | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Region, in the region's name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Kommun | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Kommun, in the municipality's name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | National (Stato). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Regione | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Regione, in the region's name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Comune | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Comune, in the city's name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | National (Staten). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Fylke | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Fylke, in the county's name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Kommune | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Kommune, in the name of the municipality. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | National (Valtio). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Wellbeing county | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Wellbeing county (hyvinvointialue). Not a province of the old kind. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Kunta | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Kunta (municipality), in the city's name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | National (Estado). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Município | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Município, in the municipality's name. No regional tier comparable to a province. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | National. Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Sveitarfélag | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Municipality. No regional tier. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | Confederation | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Confederation. Not Federal: the Swiss name of the top tier is Confederation. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Canton | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Canton, in the canton's name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Municipality | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Municipality, in the city's name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | National (United Kingdom central government). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| GLA / devolved nations | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | In London: GLA. Elsewhere: devolved administrations when they exist. Not a federated state. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Local authority | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Borough or local authority, in the municipality's name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | FEDERAL | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Federal (Bund). Austria is a federation. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Land | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Land. Vienna is both Land and city: it is not an extra tier. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Gemeinde | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Gemeinde, in the municipality's name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | FEDERAL | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Federal (Bund). Germany is a federation. Division by Germany's population. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Land | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Land, in the Land's name. Berlin is both Land and city: it is not an extra tier. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Gemeinde | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Gemeinde (Stadt), in the municipality's name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | National. City-state: the city and the country are the same tier. Not Federal, no separate municipality. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
published | National | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | National (Estado). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Comunidad autónoma | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Comunidad autónoma, in the community's name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Ayuntamiento | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Ayuntamiento, in the municipality's name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | National. Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Prefecture | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Prefecture (to). Tokyo is its prefecture: it is not an extra tier. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Municipality | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Municipality or special wards, depending on the city. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | Commonwealth | Treasury Final Budget Outcome, fiscal year 2024-25, cash basis: revenue, spending and cash balance. | Commonwealth, the name Australia gives its national tier. Divided by the country's population. Not National: Australia is a federation. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| State or territory | State accounts: for Sydney, the New South Wales parliament's Report on State Finance 2024-25. | The name of the state or territory (New South Wales, Victoria, …). Divided by the population of that state. The breakdown by function comes from the OECD, which covers the six states and the two territories TOGETHER: the series does not go down to a single state, and the page says so right where the figure is. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Council | Audited council financial statements and NSW Office of Local Government Time Series: nine observed functions, whose sum is total spending. | Council, the local name (City of Sydney). Divided by the council population, which is much smaller than the metropolitan population: 237,278 Sydney residents. Water and sewerage are zero for this council because Sydney Water is a state-owned corporation: the responsibility sits elsewhere; the spending is not missing. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | FEDERAL | União: accounts of Brazil's federal government (revenue, spending and balance). | Federal (União). Brazil is a federation. Divided by the population of Brazil. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Estado | Accounts of the federated state (São Paulo, Rio de Janeiro, etc.). | Estado, under the name of the state. Divided by the population of that state. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Município | Accounts of the município: local taxes, services, balance sheet. | Município, under the name of the municipality. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Eurostat / national accounts: state (S1311) and, when the source separates it, social security (S1314). Taxes, functions and balance. | National (state). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Local sector excluding the city | What is left of the local sector once the published municipality is removed. This is not a region: it is a named residual. | Local sector excluding the city. Not Province, not Region. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Obec / Statusární město | Municipal accounts (Obec / Statusární město): revenue, spending, functions and balance sheet when published. | Municipality or statutory city, under the name of the city. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Eurostat / national accounts: state (S1311) and, when the source separates it, social security (S1314). Taxes, functions and balance. | National (state). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Local sector excluding the city | What is left of the local sector once the published municipality is removed. This is not a region: it is a named residual. | Local sector excluding the city. Not Province, not Region. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Gmina / Miasto | Municipal accounts (Gmina / Miasto): revenue, spending, functions and balance sheet when published. | Gmina or miasto, under the name of the city. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National + provinces | Consolidated government: national and provinces, excluding municipalities. The provinces are not separated here. | National government and provinces, consolidated in the published source. Not Federal as three separate stacks. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Municipality | Accounts of the municipality (Cape Town, Tshwane, …). | Municipality, under the name of the municipality. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Eurostat / national accounts: state (S1311) and, when the source separates it, social security (S1314). Taxes, functions and balance. | National (state). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Local sector excluding the city | What is left of the local sector once the published municipality is removed. This is not a region: it is a named residual. | Local sector excluding the city. Not Province, not Region. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Pašvaldība | Municipal accounts (Pašvaldība): revenue, spending, functions and balance sheet when published. | Pašvaldība, under the name of the municipality. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Eurostat / national accounts: state (S1311) and, when the source separates it, social security (S1314). Taxes, functions and balance. | National (state). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Local sector excluding the city | What is left of the local sector once the published municipality is removed. This is not a region: it is a named residual. | Local sector excluding the city. Not Province, not Region. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Local authority | Municipal accounts (Local authority): revenue, spending, functions and balance sheet when published. | Local authority / City Council, under the name of the city. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | Couronne | Total Crown: revenue, spending and Crown balance. | Crown (Total Crown). Not Federal: New Zealand is unitary. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Council | Financial statements of the City Council. | Council, under the name of the municipality (Wellington City Council, …). | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Eurostat / national accounts: state (S1311) and, when the source separates it, social security (S1314). Taxes, functions and balance. | National (state). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Local sector excluding the city | What is left of the local sector once the published municipality is removed. This is not a region: it is a named residual. | Local sector excluding the city. Not Province, not Region. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Občina | Municipal accounts (Občina): revenue, spending, functions and balance sheet when published. | Občina, under the name of the municipality. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Eurostat / national accounts: state (S1311) and, when the source separates it, social security (S1314). Taxes, functions and balance. | National (state). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Local sector excluding the city | What is left of the local sector once the published municipality is removed. This is not a region: it is a named residual. | Local sector excluding the city. Not Province, not Region. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Grad / Općina | Municipal accounts (Grad / Općina): revenue, spending, functions and balance sheet when published. | Grad or općina, under the name of the city. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Eurostat / national accounts: state (S1311) and, when the source separates it, social security (S1314). Taxes, functions and balance. | National (state). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Local sector excluding the city | What is left of the local sector once the published municipality is removed. This is not a region: it is a named residual. | Local sector excluding the city. Not Province, not Region. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Obec / Mesto | Municipal accounts (Obec / Mesto): revenue, spending, functions and balance sheet when published. | Obec or mesto, under the name of the city. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Eurostat / national accounts: state (S1311) and, when the source separates it, social security (S1314). Taxes, functions and balance. | National (state). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Local sector excluding the city | What is left of the local sector once the published municipality is removed. This is not a region: it is a named residual. | Local sector excluding the city. Not Province, not Region. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Municipality | Municipal accounts (Municipality): revenue, spending, functions and balance sheet when published. | Municipality, under the name of the city. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | National. Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| If | Official tier accounts: revenue, spending and balance. Stocks (assets and debt) when the source separates them. | Si (city). Two tiers in the accounts we have: national and local. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Chilean general government (S13) excluding the published municipality: named derived tier. | National. Not Federal: Chile is unitary. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Municipalidad | Municipalidad accounts: revenue, spending and balance sheet. | Municipalidad, under the name of the municipality. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | Administración Central, decentralized bodies and social-security institutions, as separated by the source. | National (Administración Central). Not Federal as a stack label: the provinces carry their own name. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Provincia / CABA | Argentine province, or Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires (city-province). | Provincia, under the name of the province. Buenos Aires is an autonomous city: municipality and province in the same named tier. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Municipio | Municipal accounts outside CABA, when published separately. | Municipio, under the name of the municipality. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | National | State (S1311) and social security (S1314). | National (Estado). Not Federal. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Local sector excluding the city | Remainder of Colombia's local sector after removing the published distrito or municipio. | Local sector excluding the city. No Departamento is named here. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Distrito / Municipio | Accounts of the distrito or municipio (Bogotá, …). | Distrito or Municipio, under the name of the city. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
published | FEDERAL | Federación (S1311) and, when separated, social security (S1314). | Federal (Federación). Mexico is a federation. Divided by the population of Mexico. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. |
| Estado | Accounts of the Estados federados (S1312), aggregate or named. | Estado, under the name of the federated state. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
| Municipio | Municipio accounts: revenue, spending and balance sheet. | Municipio, under the name of the municipality. | Public finances: revenue, spending, balance (G equals T plus D), each ÷ residents of the same tier. Breakdown and comparator. Assets and debt when the stock is published. | |
Populations
Each tier is divided by the population it serves: the Canadian federal government by the population of Canada, the municipality by the municipal population. The same transfer counted per Canadian and then per Montrealer therefore changes its per-capita amount without a single extra dollar changing hands. This denominator effect is named, never confused with a deficit.
Tier populations are not added together. No per-capita value is stored: it is recalculated at each publication from the official lines.
Transfers
One government often funds another: equalization, health transfers, grants to municipalities. A transfer is spending for the payer and revenue for the recipient. Read tier by tier, it appears on both sides; in a consolidated view, it is counted only once.
Analytical sum and consolidation
The sum of the tiers serving one resident is called the resident’s public footprint. It is an analytical sum: each tier stays labelled and divided by its own population. It is not a consolidation in the sense of the IMF Government Finance Statistics manual, which removes internal flows within one sector.
The G = T + D identity
On views that stack a city’s tiers, public spending per capita (G) equals own revenue (T) plus D. D is not “the deficit”. It is the remainder after T, always calculated the same way:
- deficits declared by the tiers (the borrowing lines of their accounts);
- the denominator effect of transfers between tiers (same nominal amount, different populations);
- the rounding reconciliation gap, isolated;
- any municipal surplus, subtracted from G rather than swallowed into D.
The same identity serves the city page, the flow diagram and spending by category: three views of one city cannot publish three values of G.
Canada: StatCan and AFR
In Canada, two federal sources coexist. They do not measure the same thing, and one does not replace the other.
- AFR: the Annual Financial Report and Public Accounts of the Government of Canada, national scope, all of Canada.
- StatCan 36-10-0450: federal-tier revenue and spending measured within a province (Alberta, Quebec, Ontario and British Columbia windows).
A federal balance read in a provincial window is not Canada’s AFR balance. The two are named separately; adding them together, or substituting one for the other, is excluded.
Spending and revenue
Spending is classified by function under COFOG, the United Nations Classification of the Functions of Government. Revenue is grouped into families based on the IMF Government Finance Statistics manual: taxes, contributions, transfers, sales, property income and other revenue.
Classification
The interface uses everyday names: Health, Education, Transport. The COFOG code and the reason for the match appear in each category’s detail. COFOG has ten divisions, split into groups and classes; the sub-categories shown are those of the loaded version, and a local extension stays named as such. COFOG describes spending only; it does not classify revenue.
Observed or borrowed: where a breakdown comes from
An amount and its breakdown are two distinct facts, and they do not always come from the same source. A government almost always publishes how much it spent. It does not always publish the functional breakdown of that spending; in that case the shape must come from elsewhere, and the site shows which one it used:
- observed shape: the breakdown comes from the jurisdiction’s own accounts, the only shape that truly describes this government;
- borrowed shape: the breakdown comes from a broader series that includes the jurisdiction without going down to it; the jurisdiction is then allocated by its group’s average, and the site writes what the series actually covers;
- none: no breakdown is shown.
Worked case, Australia. Until 14 September 2026, the breakdown for the federal tier and for New South Wales, on the Sydney page, came from an international series whose state sub-sector covers the six states and two territories together. It now comes from the state’s own functional accounts, published by the national statistical office. Debt interest is a separate line there, AUD 8,010 million for New South Wales in 2024-25. The federal tier carried AUD 26,721 per capita on the Sydney page and 27,396 on the other four Australian pages; it now carries the same value everywhere.
Sources: Australian Bureau of Statistics, Government Finance Statistics 2024-25, purpose expenditure tables, read 13 September 2026.
Mixed envelopes
Some sources publish a single line for several functions, for example health and social services. Such an envelope stays flagged as mixed wherever it appears. It is not split between functions without a breakdown published by the source.
Inclusions
For each category, three questions stay separate: does the service exist in this territory, is its amount broken out in the tier’s accounts, and who benefits from it. The absence of a separate amount does not mean the absence of the service; an unpublished figure is not zero.
Revenue
Borrowing, surplus carry-forwards and fund movements are not revenue for the year: the “Borrowing and financial movements” family names them separately. Counting them as a tax would inflate own revenue and make a deficit disappear.
Balance
The balance is the difference between revenue and spending for the same scope and fiscal year, read on the same scale as the two bars. It is distinct from financing (borrowing and repayments), from the change in debt and from the effect of transfers between tiers.
Assets and debts
Assets and liabilities are stocks published in each government’s financial statements, at their book value. They describe what a government holds and what it owes at the closing date.
Standard tree
Public wealth is read in two branches. Assets: non-financial assets (infrastructure, buildings, land, equipment) and financial assets (cash, investments, receivables, equity holdings). Liabilities: financial debt (loans, bonds) and other liabilities (obligations to staff, suppliers, deferred revenue).
City pages still use the historical items: P1 physical capital, P3 financial assets, P2 and P4 subsets already counted in those two items, P5 natural resources (to come), D1 debt and liabilities, D2 infrastructure deficit. A sub-item is never added a second time to its parent item.
Valuation
Amounts are published book values, most often at depreciated historical cost: neither a sale price nor a replacement cost. Two frameworks can value the same asset differently; one country capitalizes a road and depreciates it, another expenses it in the year of construction.
Recognising an accounting framework by its numbers
The same word does not mean the same thing under every chart of accounts that produces it. The costliest case is total liabilities, which in some frameworks includes equity and in others does not. Taken at face value, it turns a government’s net worth into debt. When two frameworks coexist in a country, the site does not trust the document title: it tests the numbers.
Worked case, Greece. Two charts of accounts apply in parallel for fiscal years 2023 and 2024. The city of Athens published two balance sheets for the same 2023 year, one per framework. They make it possible to state a test and verify it:
If printed total liabilities equal total assets, the document belongs to the older framework, and its liabilities include equity.
The check lands to the cent. In the older document, the sum of lines that are not equity is EUR 161,102,443.93. In the newer document, total liabilities are EUR 161,102,443.93. Gap zero. The asset gap between the two versions, EUR 467,613.32, is absorbed entirely by equity. Without this test, a Greek municipality’s debt would be overstated by the whole of its equity: for Athens in 2024, a factor near nine.
Source: Δήμος Αθηναίων, 2023 balance sheets under both frameworks and 2024 balance sheet, read 13 September 2026.
Enterprises and funds
Equity holdings in public corporations appear among the financial assets of the government that holds them. A fund managed on behalf of depositors does not belong to its manager: the net assets managed by the Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec are not added to the Québec government’s balance sheet (case detailed under Sources and comparability).
Debt and liabilities
Financial debt is one part of liabilities. Liabilities also include pension obligations, accounts payable and other obligations. Debt, liability, deficit and financing are not synonyms: the deficit is a flow for the year, debt is a stock, and financing is how the deficit is covered.
Maintenance
An infrastructure maintenance deficit, when published, is read next to the assets it relates to. It is not automatically added to accounting liabilities and is never counted as an asset. When not published, it stays named “to come”, which is not zero.
Taxation
Taxation presents a scenario: the taxes and contributions a typical employee would pay in a city, for a chosen income. A scenario is not a personal tax bill.
Scenario
The scenario describes a typical employee, for a gross annual income chosen from a grid specific to each currency. It applies the rules of the year shown. Credits and benefits tied to a personal situation (children, housing, disability) are not part of the base scenario, and the taxation page says so.
Rules and rates
Statutory rates and brackets come from tax laws and tax administrations; they are read-only in the scenario. The average rate divides total taxes and contributions by gross income. The marginal rate applies to the next dollar earned; it never describes the total bill.
Tax bases
Each levy has its base: wages for income tax and contributions, taxable consumption for sales taxes, property value for property tax. Bases outside the paycheque (consumption, housing) are scenario assumptions.
Fixed or income-dependent assumptions
Each assumption is marked observed when it comes from a source for the city, illustrative when it is a rule of thumb. An assumption can be fixed or vary with income: estimated property tax multiplies the home’s value by the observed rate, and the home’s value, expressed as a multiple of income, changes with income. Assumptions are editable and named; statutory rates are not.
Benefits and coverage
Employer contributions do not appear on the employee’s pay, but they are part of the OECD tax wedge, which divides income tax and contributions by the total cost of labour. Levies not yet connected are named on each city’s taxation page, with their tier and whether they are included in the total.
Sources and comparability
Each published value is linked to an institution, a source, a period and a territory. Two figures are compared only when their concepts, periods, territories and responsibilities are close enough; otherwise the difference is named and no rank is given.
Evidence and transformations
Official data come first: statistical agencies’ interfaces, then documents published by governments. Conversions, divisions and scope choices are documented next to the result. A module’s Sources table shows the original lines for the current selection; this page does not replace it.
Sources and retrieval dates
Each row states what the source provides, when it was retrieved for the current publication, and the size of the data file it feeds. “Date absent from the source” is written as such where the source does not date its own release. 30 dated source(s) feed this publication · 2 named gap(s).
| Source | What it provides | Retrieved | Size |
|---|---|---|---|
| Official accounts: the six published countries | |||
| Canada: AFR, Public Accounts, StatCan, MAMH | federal, 10 provinces, Canadian cities: CAD, millions | 2026-07-23 | 37 KB |
| StatCan: 36-10-0222, provincial GDP at market prices | GDP of each province, current prices; ÷ population 17-10-0009 for the same year: not a national prorating | 2026-08-26 01:12 | 7 KB |
| Accounts by tier: US and Western Europe | municipal, state and national balances of published cities outside Canada | 2026-07-24 | 283 KB |
| US Treasury Fiscal Data: Monthly Treasury Statement | actual US federal figures, to the dollar, fiscal year ending in September | 2026-08-02 00:54 | 179 KB |
| Census: Individual Unit Files 2024 | US states, ASLGF revenue and spending, thousands of USD | date absent from the source | 10 KB |
| Eurostat: gov_10a_main, gov_10a_exp, gov_10a_taxag | revenue, spending and ESA 2010 taxes: S13 and subsectors, 30 countries | 2026-08-26 11:46 | 1,089 KB |
| Statistics Denmark: REGK4 | Danish municipal balance sheet, accounts by function | 2026-08-19 18:02 | 36 KB |
| Statistics Denmark: REGK4, aggregated balance sheet | assets and liabilities of published Danish municipalities | 2026-08-26 | 172 KB |
| Statistics Estonia: RR302 / RR300 | functions and scopes of Estonian cities | 2026-08-24 | 7 KB |
| Lithuania: Ministry of Finance, state functions | spending by function, outturn column, Lithuanian cities | 2026-08-24 | 5 KB |
| Québec: MAMH, actual financial data 2024 | balance sheets of published Québec cities | 2026-08-24 | 14 KB |
| Ontario: FIR, schedule 70X, 2024 | balance sheets of published Ontario cities | 2026-08-24 | 20 KB |
| Alberta: MFS, schedule A, 2024 | balance sheets of published Alberta cities | 2026-08-24 | 4 KB |
| British Columbia: LGDE, 2024 | balance sheets of published British Columbia cities | 2026-08-25 | 3 KB |
| Canada: provincial balance sheets, 2024 | assets and debts of the provinces, not of cities | 2026-08-24 | 11 KB |
| Country modules: health, economy, population, defence | |||
| WHO: Global Health Observatory | health: country granularity, indicators under their official label | 2026-08-22 18:33 | 6,564 KB |
| UN: World Population Prospects 2024 | demographics and projections, medium variant: countries; Census Gazetteer for US land areas | 2026-08-22 12:33 | 2,844 KB |
| World Bank: batches 4 and 5 | poverty, SIPRI defence, agriculture, energy, greenhouse gases, telecommunications, transport: countries | 2026-08-22 16:51 | 831 KB |
| World Bank + Eurostat crim_ + ACS | education, homicides, median housing in the United States | 2026-08-22 16:51 | 329 KB |
| IMF: World Economic Outlook (DBnomics) | GDP and national aggregates; future years are projections, named | 2026-08-22 17:55 | 435 KB |
| Economy: World Bank, WEO, Eurostat met_10r_3gdp | country GDP and metro GDP; a metro figure is never presented as a city figure | 2026-08-22 17:55 | 647 KB |
| OECD: Cities & FUAs | metropolitan indicators, normalized labels | 2026-08-22 23:49 | 2,434 KB |
| Eurostat: urb_* European cities | urban statistics, normalized labels | 2026-08-31 21:46 | 1,399 KB |
| ILO: ILOSTAT SDMX, wages | monthly earnings, country granularity | 2026-08-02 19:39 | 130 KB |
| NATO: Defence Expenditure 2014-2025 | defence effort, % of GDP, USD per capita; 2024-25 are the report’s estimates, named | date absent from the source | 9 KB |
| Balance sheets, functions, exchange rates, map | |||
| IMF GFS: COFOG (DBnomics) | spending by function, general government, normalized labels | 2026-08-22 19:23 | 3,347 KB |
| IMF GFS: integrated balance sheet (GFSIBS) | financial instruments by sub-sector; a city balance sheet exists in no open API: named gap | 2026-08-22 16:52 | 39 KB |
| Eurostat: nasa_10_f_bs | financial balance sheets by institutional sector | 2026-08-22 18:24 | 1,634 KB |
| Intermediate tiers: GFS | regional and local shares, % of GDP, 126 countries queried | 2026-08-22 18:35 | 36 KB |
| City assets: official extracts | municipal balance sheets where the source file publishes them | 2026-08-22 23:42 | 65 KB |
| ECB via frankfurter | exchange rates, daily average over each fiscal-year window | 2026-09-08 21:51 | 28 KB |
| Geocoding: Open-Meteo | coordinates of published cities: geography, not finances | 2026-09-08 10:26 | 122 KB |
Comparison frame: fiscal years, standards, statuses
On the comparator, a warning appears as soon as the selection mixes different fiscal years, accounting bases or observation statuses. It does not say the figures are wrong: it refuses to present them as one uniform snapshot.
What “same frame” means
- the fiscal year: the year or window of the accounts; 2024 and 2025 are not the same picture;
- the accounting basis: the rules that define what counts as an asset, liability, revenue or spending (PSAS, AASB, M57 and others);
- the observation status: audited accounts, or a figure derived from an official aggregate, always named.
What it changes in practice
Montréal, Sydney and Milan can be read side by side. A ranking of “who is richest or most indebted” cannot be read as if the rules were the same. A one-year gap can reflect inflation, a crisis or the calendar. A converted currency aligns the unit, not the calendar or the accounting framework.
How to read the comparator warning
- amounts stay on screen, each in its own unit and fiscal year;
- an automatic order is not a conclusion when the rules differ;
- for a firm conclusion, narrow the selection to one fiscal year and one family of standards, or read the gaps as named orders of magnitude.
Accounting standards, country by country
Each published country carries the framework GovXRay recorded. The short code is the one used in the comparator warning; the sentence states what the standard requires. A country missing from the table shows “basis not published” in the comparator.
| Country | Code | What the standard requires |
|---|---|---|
| Canada | PSAS | Canadian public sector accounting standards, accrual basis |
| Australia | AASB | Australian accounting standards of the Australian Accounting Standards Board, required of municipal councils by state local government acts: accrual basis |
| France | M57 | M57 budgetary and accounting framework, accrual basis: extended to local authorities since 2024 |
| Italy | D.LGS 118/2011 | accounting harmonisation of Italian local authorities: strengthened financial accounting and a balance-sheet component |
| Sweden | LKBR | lag (2018:597) om kommunal bokföring och redovisning: Swedish municipal accounting, accrual basis |
| Brazil | MCASP/NBC TSP | Manual de Contabilidade Aplicada ao Setor Público of the Secretaria do Tesouro Nacional and NBC TSP standards of the Conselho Federal de Contabilidade, converging with international public sector standards: accrual basis |
| United States | GASB | US public sector standards |
| United Kingdom | CIPFA/IFRS | CIPFA Code of Practice: IFRS adapted for UK local authorities |
| Germany | DOPPIK | municipal accrual accounting (NKF/NKHR depending on the Land); Berlin still uses extended cameral accounting: a named difference |
| Norway | KOSTRA | Norwegian municipal reporting framework |
| Spain | ICAL 2013 | instrucción de contabilidad para la administración local: accrual basis (order HAP/1781/2013) |
| Netherlands | BBV | Besluit begroting en verantwoording provincies en gemeenten: modified accrual basis |
| Japan | TOITSU-KIJUN | unified accrual accounting standards for Japanese local governments (2015 MIC reform) |
| Argentina | CABA-Ley70 | Normas de Contabilidad para el Sector Público of the Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires (Ley 70): accrual accounting (devengado), historical cost; no national framework for other municipalities |
| Austria | VRV 2015 | Voranschlags- und Rechnungsabschlussverordnung 2015: accrual accounting with three components (results, financing, balance sheet) |
| Switzerland | HRM2 | Harmonised accounting model 2 for Swiss cantons and municipalities |
| Chile | NICSP-CGR | Normativa del Sistema de Contabilidad General de la Nación for the municipal sector, issued by the Contraloría General de la República based on IPSAS: accrual basis |
| Colombia | CGN Res. 533 | Marco Normativo para Entidades de Gobierno of the Contaduría General de la Nación, indirect adoption of IPSAS, applicable to mayoralties and governorates: accrual basis |
| Czechia | Vyhláška 410/2009 | Ministry of Finance decree under Act 563/1991 on accounting, applicable to territorial authorities and their associations: accrual basis |
| Denmark | REGNSKAB | Budget- og regnskabssystem for kommuner: modified accrual basis set by the Danish Ministry of the Interior |
| Estonia | RTJ-PUBLIC | Estonian public sector accounting rules, accrual basis aligned with IPSAS (Accounting Act) |
| Finland | KUNTALAKI | Finnish municipal accrual accounting (Kuntalaki and guidance of the accounting board, municipal section) |
| Croatia | PPR | Pravilnik o proračunskom računovodstvu i Računskom planu of the Minister of Finance, issued under the Budget Act: modified accrual basis, revenue recorded when received and expenses when incurred |
| Ireland | ACoP | Accounting Code of Practice on local authority accounting, revised by the Department of Housing and Local Government: modified accrual basis, pensions recorded when paid and depreciation neutralised |
| Israel | MOI 1988 | 1988 regulations on local authority accounts and Ministry of the Interior instructions: modified cash basis |
| Iceland | L.138/2011 | annual accounts of the sveitarfélög: Icelandic Act 138/2011 on local government finances, accrual basis |
| Korea | K-LOCAL ACCRUAL | double-entry accrual accounting for Korean local governments (Local Accounting Act, 2007) |
| Lithuania | VSAFAS | Lithuanian public sector accounting and financial reporting standards, accrual basis |
| Latvia | MK 87 | Cabinet of Ministers regulation No. 87 on accounting in budgetary institutions, supplemented by the annual accounts regulation applicable to local governments: accrual basis |
| Mexico | LGCG/CONAC | Ley General de Contabilidad Gubernamental and standards of the Consejo Nacional de Armonización Contable, mandatory for municipalities: accrual basis |
| New Zealand | PBE IPSAS | PBE Standards of the External Reporting Board, the New Zealand adaptation of international public sector standards applied to local authorities: accrual basis |
| Poland | UoR/UFP | Accounting Act and Public Finance Act, implemented by the Minister of Finance regulation on budgetary accounting: modified accrual basis, budget revenue and spending being recorded on the payment date |
| Portugal | SNC-AP | Portuguese public administration accounting standards system (2015), aligned with IPSAS |
| Singapore | FPA-CASH | Financial Procedure Act: cash budget of the Singapore government, reserves protected by the Constitution |
| Slovenia | ZR | Zakon o računovodstvu and the rules on classifying and measuring revenue and expenses of public law entities: cash basis for municipal revenue and expenses, the balance sheet being kept on an accrual basis |
| Slovakia | ZoÚ 431/2002 | Accounting Act and Ministry of Finance order setting accounting procedures for municipalities and regions: accrual basis |
| South Africa | GRAP | Standards of Generally Recognised Accounting Practice of the Accounting Standards Board, required of municipalities by the Municipal Finance Management Act and based on international public sector standards: accrual basis |
How a standard changes the picture
- Cash or accrual. On a cash basis, money coming in and going out is counted. On an accrual basis (PSAS, AASB, M57, LKBR, MCASP and others), obligations and entitlements are counted when they arise. A city balanced on a cash basis can be in deficit on an accrual basis, and the reverse also happens.
- Balance sheet or budget. Some standards (M57, D.Lgs 118/2011, HRM2, DOPPIK) require a balance-sheet component: assets and debts appear on the balance sheet. Other frameworks remain budgetary and the stock is partial. Comparing complete assets per capita with a partial stock is comparing a photograph with a sketch.
- PSAS (Canada): infrastructure on the balance sheet, depreciation, pension liabilities under PSAS rules; a PSAS balance is not a cash balance. M57 (France): budget, administrative account and balance-sheet component; the M57 result is not Eurostat’s B9 balance. LKBR (Sweden): accrual basis; regions and municipalities publish separate balance sheets.
GDP and exchange rates
A ratio to GDP uses a numerator and a GDP for the same territory and year. A municipal GDP is not reconstructed by prorating a national or metropolitan GDP: when absent from the source, it is named. Tier GDPs, populations and percentages are not added together. Currency conversion is described under Reading the figures.
Limitations and gaps
The site does not fill a hole with an estimate, a national average applied to a city or a projection: a module without a source stays greyed out and named. It does not present a country figure as a city figure, or the reverse, and does not compare two different scopes in the same table without saying so. It does not compute a statistic from already aggregated statistics: a median of medians or a mean of means describes no real population.
Four kinds of gap
Not published. The government does not produce the document. Philippine local governments have no accessible consolidated balance sheet; the audit-office index stops before the year sought.
Not published by choice. The government produces the information and decides not to make it public. Singapore’s Ministry of Finance writes that it is not in the national interest to publish the full size of the reserves. It is a decision, and naming it informs more than an estimate would.
Published behind a closed gate. The document is public, but its publisher protects its pages against automated access. The site does not bypass an anti-robot device, an image check or a rate limit. The gate is named and the figure stays absent.
Not yet read. The document exists, it is accessible, and nobody has opened it. It is the only gap closed by work; the Coverage page distinguishes it from the other three.
Concrete cases: what the rules kept out
These examples show why a figure can be public and still not enter GovXRay as published. Each case names the government, scope, period, unit and source that justify the treatment.
- Balancing entry, the Land of Baden-Württemberg. At December 31, 2024, the Land's balance-sheet total is EUR 292.0 billion. It includes EUR 204.4 billion of Saldo, a balancing entry for the uncovered deficit that is not an asset. The assets retained are therefore EUR 87.6 billion. Counting the Saldo as wealth would multiply the Land's assets by 3.3. Land Vermögensrechnung 2024, pages 14 to 15.
- Manager and owner, Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec. At December 31, 2025, the CAD 517,256 million in net assets managed by CDPQ belong to its depositors, including public and parapublic pension and insurance plans. This portfolio is not an unrestricted asset of the Québec government and is not added to its balance sheet. CDPQ 2025 Annual Report.
- Municipal scope, Istanbul. Law 6360 extends the jurisdiction of İstanbul Büyükşehir Belediyesi to the provincial boundary. This metropolitan government therefore covers the province's 15,754,053 residents at December 31, 2025. It cannot be treated as a European municipality carrying the same city name. This case is the symptom of a two-regime territorial structure, described below. Law 6360; 2025 ADNKS results, General Directorate of Population.
- Budget headline, Dimos Porou. In the 2025 budget of the Greek municipality of Poros, the displayed total is EUR 19.6 million, but resources in groups 0, 1 and 2 amount to EUR 6.6 million. Groups 3, 4 and 5, or 66.2% of the displayed total, are borrowing, arrears receivable, collections on behalf of third parties and a cash balance carried forward. The Greek classification isolates these items itself; GovXRay does not publish them as revenue for the year. Dimos Porou, decision 151/2024, 2025 budget.
- Rounding tolerance, State of Michigan. The State's balance sheet at September 30, 2025, page 34, prints five terms in millions of USD to one decimal place, a printing step of USD 100,000. The tolerance specific to this document is therefore USD 100,000 × 5 ÷ 2 = USD 250,000. The observed USD 100,000 gap is source rounding; a gap above USD 250,000 would be an error. Michigan Annual Comprehensive Financial Report 2025, page 34.
- Dual perimeter, Taiwan's special municipalities. Each municipality publishes two balance sheets in its final accounts: agencies only, and a consolidated sheet that adds enterprise funds. For fiscal year 2024, the gap between the two is 2.0% in Taipei, 18.7% in Kaohsiung and 23.3% in Taichung. Cities are comparable only on the same table. The site keeps the agencies perimeter, the common one across the five cities read, and keeps the consolidated figure named beside it. Final accounts 2024 for each city, cross-checked against audit-office reports, read 15 September 2026.
- A third unit, Taipei final accounts. The summary table at the head of the document is labelled in hundreds of millions of New Taiwan dollars, neither units nor thousands. One document can therefore carry three different units depending on the page. Amounts retained by the site come from the explanatory text, where the unit is the unit. Same source as the previous case.
- Two territorial regimes, Turkey. A 2012 reform extended thirty metropolitan governments to their provincial boundaries and abolished the provincial administration in those thirty provinces; the other fifty-one kept it. There is therefore not one Turkish territorial structure but two, and the tier above a municipality depends on which province it sits in. One effect of that reform deserves stating: the property-tax law doubles its rates inside a metropolitan jurisdiction, and once that jurisdiction became provincial, rural property tax doubled in thirty provinces without any change to the tax statute itself. Law 6360, article 1; Law 1319, articles 8 and 18, read 13 September 2026.
- A higher bar, the comparable set. When a scope or definition rule tightens, a city that no longer meets it leaves the ranked set. The Coverage page names the city and the reason. The site prefers reducing coverage to preserving an unverifiable rank.
Checks and revisions
The Method page is built last. It rereads the 3,368 pages produced, finds every division printed as “x % = a ÷ b” and recomputes it. The figures below are those of the 2026-09-25 02:21 UTC publication. Scope of this check: printed divisions, internal links and page weight. It does not verify the source data themselves.
An entity is shown when its accounts pass the checks; otherwise it is withdrawn and named on the Coverage page, with the reason. When a concept is replaced, the replacement is written on the page that carries it: the former “surplus” became the scope balance, because it measured only an accounting scope.
Dates, fiscal years and data versions are kept with each observation; a browsable history of revisions is not yet published. An export or a citation must keep the source, period, unit and data version of the result shown.
Page published 2026-09-25 02:21 UTC. Who publishes the site and how to reach the publisher: About · Coverage · Home.